Feature Image: Former T.B. Guest & Co. Biscuit Factory converted to apartments in 2003

As Victoria grapples with increasing housing demand, the Victorian Government has introduced the Great Design Fast Track (GDFT) initiative—a streamlined planning process that rewards well-designed housing through seven key design principles. While the GDFT’s focus on design quality is commendable, the program is limited in its scope, addressing only new builds and therefore inadvertently encouraging demolition of existing structures and established trees. 

The National Trust has significant concerns about this approach. By focusing exclusively on new construction, the GDFT overlooks the substantial potential of adaptive reuse—a powerful sustainable development tool that contributes less waste, helps mitigate climate impacts, and creates far more interesting and diverse neighbourhoods than a knock-down-and-replace mentality. 

We have used the State Design Book nomination process as an opportunity to draw attention to how adaptive reuse of existing buildings can offer genuine solutions to Victoria’s housing needs. Rather than viewing heritage as a barrier to housing supply, our nominations demonstrate how thoughtful integration of heritage considerations can result in high-quality, context-sensitive housing and urban design outcomes that benefit both residents and the broader community. 

The National Trust has also identified a major omission in the exhibited Great Design Principles – the development of neighbourly and sustainable homes through adaptive re-use and retrofit of existing quality buildings. We know that such developments produce innovative and great design outcomes alongside retention of valued heritage and can offer fast-track approval opportunities. We are therefore urging the Department of Transport and Planning to incorporate adaptive reuse and retrofit developments of existing building into the Great Design Principles and Fast Track program.

 The TIMBY Philosophy in Action 

These nominations embody what we call TIMBY —Thoughtfully In My Backyard. Rather than viewing heritage as a barrier to housing, these projects demonstrate how careful integration of heritage considerations can result in high-quality, context-sensitive housing outcomes that benefit both residents and the broader community. 

Projects were sourced from recommendations by NTAV staff and members of our Heritage Advocacy Committee (HAC). The nominations span three key categories that align with the GDFT’s scope: townhouses (2-3 storeys), low-rise apartments (up to 5 storeys), and mid-rise apartments (up to 8 storeys). Each exemplifies how the GDFT’s design principles—particularly “Neighbourly homes” and “Sustainable homes”—can be achieved while respecting heritage values.

Image: Harold Street Middle Park. Source: Matyas Architects & Interiors

Townhouse Excellence: Small Scale, Big Impact 

Among our townhouse nominations, is Banbury Village in Footscray, a large-scale redevelopment of an industrial site, the former Olympic Tyre & Rubber Factory in Footscray into a residential community. The development preserves the original factory structures at the front to maintain the site’s historical significance and adding to the richness and character of the development.

The Davison Collaborative in Brunswick (suggested by HAC member Soon-Tzu Speechley) takes a different but equally thoughtful approach. This sustainable infill project replaced a single post-war home with three all-electric townhouses, achieving an impressive 8+ NatHERS rating while reflecting the area’s industrial heritage. Developed under a collaborative model, it shows how innovative delivery approaches can support both environmental and heritage goals. 

77 Kay Street, Carlton (suggested by HAC member James Lesh) represents another exemplary approach to heritage-sensitive infill. This 1982 project by Peter Corrigan of Edmond and Corrigan marked a creative shift in public housing design, demonstrating how public housing can be both innovative and sensitive to existing contexts. The project showcases that thoughtful integration of housing into established neighbourhoods can be both adventurous and reflective of suburban character. 

The Harold Street project in Middle Park (suggested by NTAV Environmental Advocate, Katherine Masiulanis) stands out for its sensitive approach to heritage-rich environments. Using brick and timber elements that echo the area’s material character, this development successfully navigates heritage overlays through careful form and detailing. Green space is carefully maintained and integrated into the design, including a small roof terrace and additional tree planting.  It demonstrates how contemporary housing can enhance rather than compromise local identity. 

Adaptive Reuse: Breathing New Life into Historic Structures 

Our mid-rise nominations showcase the transformative potential of adaptive reuse.  

The MacRobertson Confectionery Factory conversion in Fitzroy (suggested by HAC member James Murray) exemplifies how industrial heritage can be sensitively transformed into contemporary housing while retaining character-defining elements like exposed brick and timber beams. 

Image: Former MacRobertson Confectionery Factory conversion, Fitzroy

The Wertheim Factory conversion in Richmond (suggested by NTAV Executive Manager – Conservation & Advocacy, Samantha Westbrooke) demonstrates heritage award-winning architecture, successfully blending the building’s piano factory origins with modern residential needs and green spaces.  

Image: Former Wertheim Factory, Richmond

The former TB Guest Biscuit Factory in West Melbourne, built 1897 and converted to residential apartments in 2002, is an excellent example of adaptive re-use that retains the existing exterior envelope and interior factory features while allowing for upgrades and contemporary living spaces. 

Image: Former TB Guest & Co. Biscuit Factory, West Melbourne

These projects prove that adaptive reuse can deliver both heritage preservation and housing supply. 

Green Space Integration: Landscape-Led Development 

Yubup Park in Frith Street, Brunswick (suggested by NTAV Heritage Services Coordinator Eleni Courvisanos) represents an innovative approach to heritage-sensitive development to provide parkland in built up housing areas. This project combines retention of former industrial buildings and elements with open space and Indigenous planting to provide a vibrant community park. Developed in collaboration with community members and Traditional Owners, it exemplifies how heritage considerations can extend beyond built form to encompass cultural and environmental heritage. 

Learning from Success 

What unites all these nominations is their commitment to context sensitivity. Whether through material choice, scale consideration, or adaptive reuse strategies, each project demonstrates that heritage and housing are not mutually exclusive. Instead, they show how heritage considerations can inform and elevate housing design. 

Image: Park Street, Brunswick, Oxley Lodge Source: BREATHE Architecture

The Park Street project by Breathe Architecture (suggested by Samantha Westbrooke) particularly embodies the “do more with less” philosophy, revitalising structures that were nearing the end of their functional life. By embracing existing structures and making thoughtful upgrades, the project transforms perceived constraints into design strengths and provided fast track approval and construction pathways. 

Looking Forward 

These nominations to the State Design Book represent more than just good buildings—they’re blueprints for how Victoria can address its housing challenges while preserving what makes our neighbourhoods special. They demonstrate that the GDFT’s vision of sustainable, “Neighbourly homes” that enhance local identity is not only possible but already being achieved across Melbourne. 

As the State Design Book takes shape, we hope these projects will serve as inspiration and guidance for developers, planners, and communities. They prove that when heritage is considered thoughtfully from the outset, the result is housing that is not just well-designed and better for the planet, but genuinely loved by the communities it serves. 

Image: The historic factory buildings at the front of the Banbury Village development